-The Blatchford Controversies (1903)
Quotes by and posts relating to one of the most influential authors of the 20th century, G.K. Chesterton
Tuesday, October 30, 2018
[Mr. Blatchford said] that although people ought not to be blamed for
their actions, yet they ought to be trained to do better. They ought,
he said, to be given better conditions of heredity and environment,
and then they would be good, and the problem would be solved.
The primary answer is obvious. How can one say that a man ought
not to be held responsible, but ought to be well trained?
For if he "ought" to be well trained, there must be somebody who "ought"
to train him. And that man must be held responsible for training him.
The proposition has killed itself in three sentences.
Mr. Blatchford has not removed the necessity for responsibility merely
by saying that humanity, instead of being dealt with by the hangmen,
ought to be dealt with by the doctors. For, upon the whole,
and supposing I required the services of either, I think I
would sooner be dealt with by an irresponsible hangman than by an irresponsible doctor.
No comments:
Post a Comment