-Charles Dickens (1906)
Quotes by and posts relating to one of the most influential authors of the 20th century, G.K. Chesterton
Wednesday, February 22, 2017
Again, the other chief accusation against Dickens was that his
characters and their actions were exaggerated and impossible. But this only
meant that they were exaggerated and impossible as compared with the modern
world and with certain writers (like Thackeray or Trollope) who were making a
very exact copy of the manners of the modern world. Some people, oddly enough,
have suggested that Dickens has suffered or will suffer from the change of
manners. Surely this is irrational. It is not the creators of the impossible
who will suffer from the process of time:
Mr. Bunsby can never be any more impossible than he was when Dickens made him.
The writers who will obviously suffer from time will be the careful and
realistic writers, the writers who have observed every detail of the fashion
of this world which passeth away. It is surely obvious that there is nothing
so fragile as a fact, that a fact flies away quicker than a fancy. A fancy
will endure for two thousand years. For instance, we all have fancy for an
entirely fearless man, a hero; and the Achilles of Homer still remains. But
exactly the thing we do not know about Achilles is how far he was possible.
The realistic narrators of the time are all forgotten (thank God), so we
cannot tell whether Homer slightly exaggerated or wildly exaggerated or did
not exaggerate at all, the personal activity of a Mycenæan captain in
battle; for the fancy has survived the facts. So the fancy of Podsnap may
survive the facts of English commerce: and no one will know whether Podsnap
was possible, but only know that he is desirable, like Achilles.
No comments:
Post a Comment