-St Thomas Aquinas: The Dumb Ox (1933)
Quotes by and posts relating to one of the most influential authors of the 20th century, G.K. Chesterton
Wednesday, December 2, 2015
Perhaps under the shadow of the storm that menaced all Friars,
Bonaventure, the Franciscan, grew into so great a friendship with Thomas
the Dominican, that their contemporaries compared them to David and
Jonathan. The point is of some interest; because it would be quite easy
to represent the Franciscan and the Dominican as flatly contradicting
each other. The Franciscan may be represented as the Father of all the
Mystics; and the Mystics can be represented as men who maintain that the
final fruition or joy of the soul is rather a sensation than a thought.
The motto of the Mystics has always been, "Taste and see." Now
St. Thomas also began by saying, "Taste and see;" but he said it of the
first rudimentary impressions of the human animal. It might well be
maintained that the Franciscan puts Taste last and the Dominican puts it
first. It might be said that the Thomist begins with something solid
like the taste of an apple, and afterwards deduces a divine life for the
intellect; while the Mystic exhausts the intellect first, and says
finally that the sense of God is something like the taste of an apple.
A common enemy might claim that St. Thomas begins with the taste of
fruit and St. Bonaventure ends with the taste of fruit. But they are
both right; if I may say so, it is a privilege of people who contradict
each other in their cosmos to be both right. The Mystic is right in
saying that the relation of God and Man is essentially a love-story; the
pattern and type of all love-stories. The Dominican rationalist is
equally right in saying that the intellect is at home in the topmost
heavens; and that the appetite for truth may outlast and even devour all
the duller appetites of man.
No comments:
Post a Comment