Now, in spite of the wildest claims to independence, the intellectual life of
today still strikes me as being mainly symbolised by the train or the track or
the groove. There is any amount of fuss and vivacity about certain fixed
fashions or directions of thought; just as there is any amount of rapidity along
the fixed rails of the railway-track. But if we begin to think about
really getting off the track, we shall find that what is true of the train is
equally true of the truth. We shall find it is actually harder to get out
of the groove, when the train is going fast, than when the train is going
slowly. We shall find that rapidity is rigidity; that the very fact of
some social or political or artistic movement going quicker and quicker means
that fewer people have the courage to move against it. And at last perhaps
nobody will make a leap for real intellectual liberty, just as nobody will jump
out of a railway-train going at eighty miles an hour. This seems to me the
primary mark of what we call progressive thought in the modern world. It
is in the most exact sense of the term limited. It is all in one
dimension. It is all in one direction. It is limited by its
progress. It is limited by its speed.
I have said that it has not the curiosity to stop. If the
train-dwellers were really travellers, exploring a strange country to make
discoveries, they would always be stopping at little wayside stations. For
instance, they would always be stopping to consider the curious nature of their
own conventional terms; a thing which they never do, by any chance. Their
catchwords are regarded solely as gadgets or appliances for getting them where
they are going to; they never cast back a thought upon where the catchword comes
from. Yet that is exactly what they would do if they were really thinking,
in any thorough and all-round sense. Of course it will be understood,
touching these intellectual fashions, that great masses, probably the mass of
mankind, never travel on the train at all. They remain in their villages
and are much happier and better; but they are not regarded as the intellectual
leaders of the time. What I complain of is that the intellectual leaders
can only lead along one narrow track; otherwise known as the ringing groove of
change.
-The Common Man (collection of essays published posthumously in 1950)
Hey!
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to let you know that this blog is amazing! I've been following Chesterton for a few years now, but never could find key passages and context that many quotations leave out. The one that led me to this site was the one on "We do not really want a religion that is right where we are right. What we want is a religion that is right where we are wrong." Anyways, keep up what you are doing! Love it!
Brandon
Thanks! :-)
ReplyDelete