-The Outlook, Volume LVVVI (September to December 1905), "The Eclipse of Sentiment"
Quotes by and posts relating to one of the most influential authors of the 20th century, G.K. Chesterton
Friday, May 1, 2015
The evil sentimentalism which we all have reason to deplore from time
to time as we pass through life is generally, I think, definable as a
tame and cold or small and inadequate manner of speaking about certain
matters which demand very large and beautiful expression. The
sentimentalist's comment on death or first love, for instance, is
offensive, not because his words are too big, but because they are not
big enough. We all feel, for instance, that if a journalist having
occasion to see the dead child of some poor woman, should in the
depravity of his nature talk of it having "a little angel face"- we all
feel, I say, that such a journalist is rather a nasty fellow. But the
reason is because the thought is in the presence of a great tragedy,
entirely trivial. the august and poignant fact about the child is not
that it looks like an angel, or is pretty, or even good; the sacred
thing about it is simply that it is dead. The tragedy is just the same
if it happens at that moment to look like a baboon. The observation is
therefore bad, not because it is emotional, but because it is not
emotional. It is bad, not because it is soft, but because it is really
very hard and cruel. It is outside the atmosphere; it is strictly to be
called "bad taste," because it has not tasted the bracing and bitter
substance of calamity. It has drunk the dreadful wine from the same cup
as the child's mother, but it has not felt the smack of the difference
between this and the weak wine of mere humanitarianism.
No comments:
Post a Comment